| Category | Costa Oil ★ | Take 5 | Valvoline | Jiffy Lube |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reputation | ||||
| Star rating | 4.9 ★ | 4.6–4.8 ★ | 4.8 ★ | Mixed |
| Review volume | 851 reviews | ~226 (3 locations) | ~105 | Low–moderate |
| Service | ||||
| Speed promise | 10 min | 10 min | 15 min | 15 min |
| Stay in car | Yes | Yes | Yes | Optional |
| No appointment | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Upsell pressure | None noted | Yes — complaints | Yes — complaints | Yes — complaints |
| Pricing — Full Synthetic Oil Change | ||||
| Full synthetic price | $59.95 | ~$77–$94 | ~$85–$110 | ~$70–$100 |
| Savings vs. Costa | — baseline — | $17–$34 more | $25–$50 more | $10–$40 more |
| Pricing — Synthetic Blend Oil Change | ||||
| Synthetic blend price | $59.95 | ~$59–$70 | ~$55–$75 | ~$65–$80 |
| Synthetic blend notes | Same price as full synthetic — best value | Castrol GTX Magnatec | Valvoline MaxLife blend | Standard blend offering |
| High Mileage Options (75,000+ mile vehicles) | ||||
| Offers high mileage? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| High mileage price | +$14.95 → $74.90 total | ~$57–$70 | ~$60–$90 | ~$60–$70 |
| High mileage product | Havoline High Mileage | Castrol GTX High Mileage | Valvoline MaxLife | Pennzoil High Mileage |
| Ownership & Trust | ||||
| Ownership | Locally owned | National franchise | National franchise | National franchise |
| Price complaints | None noted | Yes — frequent | Yes — noted | Yes — noted |
★ Costa Oil Norman, OK · 2201 W Lindsey St · Competitor pricing reflects 2026 national averages and may vary by location.